Family edition
Claw Game Maker: Build a Fair Machine
Your child designs a fair claw machine in Claw Game Maker, starting from one that is not. The point is a design loop: change one thing, test it, read the result, and keep the machine fun while every prize stays winnable.
What you need
- A computer or Chromebook with a current browser.
- The lesson link: mytekdev.com/try/clawmaker?lesson=build-a-fair-machine&ref=fam-clawmaker-4. No account, no email and nothing to install; a free account to share the machine.
Before you start: try it once yourself
Open mytekdev.com/try/clawmaker?lesson=build-a-fair-machine&ref=fam-clawmaker-4. The unfair starter: three big bears, three boxed toys, four bears and two capsule balls, under a claw with bare metal tips and grips of 1.2, 1.0 and 0.6 newtons.
- The check. Open Build, Share, and press Run the honest machine check. It names the kinds that cannot be lifted: the big bear and the boxed toy, and at these grips the bear too.
- One change. Open Claw. Pick rubber pads. Run the check: the bear passes, the big bear and the box still fail.
- Again. Turn the Grab, Lift and Carry grips up to 4, 3.5 and 2.8 N. Run the check: the big bear passes. The box needs about 4 N with three prongs or 2 N with four: pick 4 prongs.
- Tune. Open Test and run the robots. If they win most plays, bring a grip down or the pad angle back, and check again. About 7 of 20 is the target.
- Share. Win a prize from it yourself (the check asks for that too), then share it. Friends play it from the share page.
The ideas, in plain words
This is MS-ETS1 with a real constraint and a real test. The constraint comes from the trade: several states require that every prize on show in a crane game be obtainable with the claw as set, and the app's honest machine check is modeled on it. The criterion is play: a machine the robots win nine times in ten is a vending machine, and one they never win is a thief; one in three is a game.
The trade-offs are the physics of the first two parts of this series. A boxed toy has flat sides nothing can get under, so it needs a squeeze: about 4 N per prong with three rubber-padded prongs, or about 2 N with four. A grip that high makes the plush bears nearly certain, so children look for other levers: more prongs, longer prongs, a different pile.
The robots are the model that generates data for iterative testing (MS-ETS1-4). Twenty plays is a rough measure; children who want to be sure run sixty.
Do it together
- Open mytekdev.com/try/clawmaker?lesson=build-a-fair-machine&ref=fam-clawmaker-4 together. Open Build, Share, and Run the honest machine check.
You'll know it worked when: It fails and names the big bear and the boxed toy.
- Open Build, Claw. Change one thing: rubber pads, or a higher grip, or hooked pads. Run the check again.
If you get stuck: The check names what still fails; change one thing for that kind.
You'll know it worked when: Each change is for a reason your child can say.
- When it passes, open Test and run the robots. Aim for about 7 wins in 20.
You'll know it worked when: If they win nearly every play, turn a grip down and check again.
- Talk about the trade-off: what made the box liftable, and what did that do to the bears?
You'll know it worked when: Your child can name one trade-off and how they settled it.
Talk about it
Ask these while you work together. A child who has understood it can answer them without help:
- What did the check say, and what did you change for it?
- Why did rubber pads fix the bear but not the box?
- What lifted the box in the end, and what did that do to the bears?
- What is your machine's rate now, and how do you know?
- What did a friend do that you did not think of?
For younger and older kids
Younger: For a younger child, set the level to Kid and stop when the check passes.
Older: For a teenager, make the boxed toy winnable without turning the grip up: more prongs, longer ones, or a pile that stands it on end.
Keep going
- Make the box winnable without turning the grip up: four prongs, longer prongs, or a pile that stands it on end.
- Tune two machines to the same rate, one by grip and one by the pile, and compare how they feel to play.
- Put your own 3D model from the library in the box and make it winnable.
Bring it into other subjects
- Math: with a dollar a play and prizes that cost three dollars, which win rate makes the machine pay for itself?
- Civics: find whether your state has a rule on crane games and what it says.
- Art: design the cabinet and the sign in Build, Cabinet, for a theme of your own.
- English: write the fair-play notice a careful operator would post on the machine.
For your records
Ready to copy into an hour log, a portfolio or a transcript.
| Lesson | Claw Game Maker: Build a Fair Machine |
|---|---|
| Subjects | Engineering, Physical science |
| Time | 45 minutes |
| What we did | Ran a design loop on a claw machine simulation: stated criteria and a constraint, changed one thing at a time, tested with an honest-machine check and robot players, and shared the result. |
| Skills practiced | Engineering design; Testing against a constraint; Reading data from a model |
Claw Game Maker: Build a Fair Machine
Activity sheet (optional)
Name: ______________________________ Date: ______________
Open the app: scan the QR code, or go to mytekdev.com/try/clawmaker?lesson=build-a-fair-machine
Essential question: How do you make a claw machine that is fair to the player and still fun?
Warm-up: An unwinnable prize: wrong, or just hard? What would you change first? ________________________
- Vocabulary. Criteria, constraint, honest machine check, iteration, trade-off: write each in your own words.
- The design log. Each round: what I changed, why, the test I ran, the result.
- The rate. Robots won ____ of 20 with the check passing. A friend's machine: ____ of 20, and what they did: ________
1. What was your hardest trade-off, and how did you settle it?
2. Why does the check ask that the maker has won a prize too?
Quick check
Name: ______________________________
1. A constraint is (A) something a design must do well (B) a rule a design must obey (C) a change you try
2. The honest check fails on the boxed toy. The best next step is (A) turn every grip to 12 N (B) change one thing for the box and check again (C) take every prize out
3. Name one trade-off in a fair claw machine and how you would settle it.
Answers
| Question | Answer | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | B | Criteria are what it should do well; a constraint is what it must obey. |
| 2 | B | One change, one test; a maximum grip passes the check and ruins the play. |
| 3 | For example: the grip that lifts the box makes the bears easy | Settle it with another lever: more prongs, longer prongs, hooked pads, or a different pile. A full answer names the test used. |
If your state or umbrella school asks, this lesson covers NGSS MS-ETS1-1, NGSS MS-ETS1-2, NGSS MS-ETS1-3, NGSS MS-ETS1-4.