For a teacher with a class? The classroom edition has the full plan, slides and standards.

Homeschooling PDF

Family edition

Reaction Lab: Does Burning Destroy Matter?

Ages 11-14 · about 45 minutes, in one sitting

Your child burns steel wool and a candle on a scale in Reaction Lab, safely on the screen, and finds out why one gets heavier and the other lighter while no matter is destroyed.

What you need

Before you start: try it once yourself

Open mytekdev.com/try/reactionlab?lesson=does-burning-destroy-matter&ref=fam-reactionlab-4. A short guide opens over the app on the steel wool lab bench: a pad of steel wool on a dish on a kitchen scale reading 85.0 g, with a magnifier beside it.

  1. Steel wool. Light it. The strands glow and turn from gray to black, and the reading rises to 85.6 g. In the magnifier, oxygen molecules come apart and their atoms join the iron.
  2. The candle. Burning methane on the shelf, then Lab bench. The candle burns and the reading falls from 120.0 g to 119.4 g. The magnifier shows methane, the small cousin of wax, burning in the open: carbon dioxide and water vapor leave.
  3. Fix the claim. Puzzles, then Fix the claim. A friend wrote that the scale must be broken. The answer box saves with the project.
The steel wool goes against what nearly every child expects. Ask for predictions first, and keep them on the board.

The ideas, in plain words

Burning is a reaction with oxygen from the air. When iron burns, the oxygen joins it to make iron oxide, a solid, so the solid on the scale weighs more: mostly black Fe₃O₄, with some red Fe₂O₃. In a classroom only the outside of a pad burns, so the real gain is small, a few tenths of a gram for a pad of a few grams.

When a candle burns, the wax joins oxygen and leaves as carbon dioxide and water vapor, both gases that go into the room, so the candle gets lighter. In a real class that takes several minutes; the app speeds it up. In both cases no atom is made or destroyed: what changes is what stays on the scale. Light and heat are given off, and they have no mass any scale could weigh.

Research on middle school children finds that about half think burning iron loses mass, and some say a candle's light itself has mass. Both are what this lesson is aimed at.

Do it together

  1. Open mytekdev.com/try/reactionlab?lesson=does-burning-destroy-matter&ref=fam-reactionlab-4 together. A short guide opens over the app with steel wool on a scale. Ask: will it get heavier or lighter? Then press Light it.

    You'll know it worked when: The scale goes from 85.0 g to 85.6 g.

  2. Drag the magnifier over the steel wool.

    You'll know it worked when: Your child can say oxygen from the air joined the iron.

  3. Open Burning methane from the list, press Lab bench, and light the candle.

    You'll know it worked when: The candle gets lighter, and your child can say what left.

  4. Press Puzzles, then Fix the claim, and write a reply to the person who thinks the scale is broken.

    If you get stuck: Start with: the scale is not broken, because ...

    You'll know it worked when: Two sentences with the readings in them.

Talk about it

Ask these while you work together. A child who has understood it can answer them without help:

The last question is the real test: in a sealed jar the gases stay, so the mass would hold.

For younger and older kids

Younger: For a younger child, do the steel wool and talk about the magnifier.

Older: For a teenager, compare the candle with burning methane in the particle view, lid on and lid off.

Keep going

Bring it into other subjects

For your records

Ready to copy into an hour log, a portfolio or a transcript.

LessonReaction Lab: Does Burning Destroy Matter?
SubjectsPhysical science
Time45 minutes
What we didCompared burning steel wool, which gains mass, with a burning candle, which loses it, used a particle model to explain both, and wrote a claim with evidence and reasoning.
Skills practicedCombustion; Conservation of mass; Claim, evidence and reasoning

Reaction Lab: Does Burning Destroy Matter?

Activity sheet (optional)

Name: ______________________________ Date: ______________

Open the app: scan the QR code, or go to mytekdev.com/try/reactionlab?lesson=does-burning-destroy-matter

Essential question: When something burns, is matter destroyed?

Warm-up: A candle burns for an hour and gets shorter. Was some of the candle destroyed? ________________________

  1. Vocabulary. Combustion, oxygen, iron oxide, water vapor, evidence: write each in your own words.
  2. The before-and-after table. Steel wool: before ______ g, after ______ g, heavier or lighter ________, why ________________. Candle: before ______ g, after ______ g, heavier or lighter ________, why ________________.
  3. Fix the claim. My reply to the friend, with a claim, the readings as evidence, and my reasoning:

1. Steel wool got heavier and the candle got lighter. Explain both with atoms.

2. Would a candle burning in a sealed jar on a scale get lighter? Why?

Quick check

Name: ______________________________

1. Steel wool burns on a scale, open to the air. The reading after is: (A) lower (B) the same (C) higher

2. A candle burns and gets lighter because: (A) its atoms were destroyed (B) its products left as gases (C) the light took the mass

3. A friend says burning destroys matter. Write one sentence back, with evidence from today.

Answers

QuestionAnswerWhy
1COxygen from the air joins the iron to make iron oxide, which stays on the scale.
2BCarbon dioxide and water vapor leave into the room. Light has no mass any scale could weigh.
3Open answerA full answer names one reading and the atoms: for example, the steel wool got heavier because oxygen joined it, so nothing was destroyed.

If your state or umbrella school asks, this lesson covers NGSS MS-PS1-5, NGSS MS-PS1-2.