Family edition
Reaction Lab: Lid On, Lid Off
Your child does the baking soda and vinegar lab in Reaction Lab, sealed in a bag and then in an open cup, and finds out why the open cup gets lighter even though matter is never destroyed.
What you need
- A computer or Chromebook with a current browser.
- The lesson link: mytekdev.com/try/reactionlab?lesson=lid-on-lid-off&ref=fam-reactionlab-3. No account, no email and nothing to install.
- If you want to try it for real: a zip bag, a small cup of vinegar, a spoonful of baking soda, and a kitchen scale.
Before you start: try it once yourself
Open mytekdev.com/try/reactionlab?lesson=lid-on-lid-off&ref=fam-reactionlab-3. A short guide opens over the app on the zip bag lab: a sealed bag on a kitchen scale reading 152.4 g, with a magnifier beside it.
- Sealed. Tip the cup. The vinegar spills onto the baking soda, it foams, the bag puffs up, and the scale holds at 152.4 g. Drag the magnifier over the bag to see the particles.
- Open. Press Make it an open cup and tip again. Carbon dioxide bubbles away and the reading falls to 151.4 g.
- Particles. Press Particles. With the lid off, a balanced reaction ends with the carbon dioxide escaping up the neck; the scale drops by its mass and the molecules wait above the flask under "Left the flask".
The ideas, in plain words
Baking soda (sodium bicarbonate) and vinegar (acetic acid) make sodium acetate, water and carbon dioxide gas. In a closed system the carbon dioxide stays and the mass holds. In an open one it leaves, and the scale drops by its mass. Nothing is destroyed: the atoms are in the room.
Children often believe gases have no mass, especially gases they cannot see. Showing the gas as molecules that keep their mass when they leave is the point of the particle view. The research the app was built from found that open systems are the part children understand least, even after teaching.
The real lab works with a spoonful of baking soda and a small cup of vinegar; the carbon dioxide from a spoonful weighs about a gram, so the scale needs to read tenths of a gram.
Do it together
- Open mytekdev.com/try/reactionlab?lesson=lid-on-lid-off&ref=fam-reactionlab-3 together. A short guide opens over the app with the zip bag on a scale. Write down the reading, then press Tip the cup.
You'll know it worked when: The bag puffs up and the scale stays at 152.4 g.
- Press Make it an open cup, and tip it again.
You'll know it worked when: The reading drops to 151.4 g.
- Ask: where did that gram go? Then press Particles, and press React with the lid off.
If you get stuck: If the equation is not balanced, add molecules with the + buttons first.
You'll know it worked when: Your child can point to the carbon dioxide molecules that left through the top.
- Press Put the lid on, and press React again.
You'll know it worked when: The scale holds, and your child can say why the lid made the difference.
Talk about it
Ask these while you work together. A child who has understood it can answer them without help:
- Why did the sealed bag puff up?
- Where did the gram from the open cup go?
- You cannot see carbon dioxide. How do you know it has mass?
- Is the open cup a closed system or an open one?
- Why might a real sealed bag read a little lower than it should?
For younger and older kids
Younger: For a younger child, do the bag sealed and open and talk about the fizz.
Older: For a teenager, try burning methane with the lid off and compare the drop with the gases that left.
Keep going
- Burning methane with the lid off: the carbon dioxide and the hot water vapor both leave. Compare the drop with the masses.
- Work out why a puffed-up bag reads a little low, and design a container that would not.
- Find a reaction on the shelf where taking the lid off changes nothing, and say why.
Bring it into other subjects
- Math: the open cup lost 1.0 g. Carbon dioxide is 44 mass units a molecule. Which reactant was used up first, and how do you know?
- Earth science: where does the carbon dioxide from a campfire go, and what takes it back out of the air?
- English: write a lab report for the sealed bag and the open cup, with a claim, evidence and reasoning.
- Engineering: design a container for the lab that will not puff up, and say why it gives a truer reading.
For your records
Ready to copy into an hour log, a portfolio or a transcript.
| Lesson | Reaction Lab: Lid On, Lid Off |
|---|---|
| Subjects | Physical science |
| Time | 45 minutes |
| What we did | Compared a baking soda and vinegar reaction in a sealed bag and an open cup, and used a particle model to explain why the open cup lost mass. |
| Skills practiced | Open and closed systems; Gases have mass; Conservation of mass |
Reaction Lab: Lid On, Lid Off
Activity sheet (optional)
Name: ______________________________ Date: ______________
Open the app: scan the QR code, or go to mytekdev.com/try/reactionlab?lesson=lid-on-lid-off
Essential question: If mass is never destroyed, why does the scale go down when the cup is open?
Warm-up: An open can of soda sits out all day. Would it weigh less by evening? Why? ________________________
- Vocabulary. Closed system, open system, gas, carbon dioxide, conservation of mass: write each in your own words.
- The data table. Sealed bag: before ______ g, after ______ g, change ______. Open cup: before ______ g, after ______ g, change ______. Particles, lid off: before ______, after ______, molecules that left ________________.
- The magnifier. What I saw inside the bag: ____________________________________.
1. Where did the mass from the open cup go?
2. Why might a real sealed bag that puffs up read a little lower than it should?
Quick check
Name: ______________________________
1. Baking soda and vinegar react in a sealed bag on a scale. The reading after is: (A) lower (B) the same (C) higher
2. The same reaction in an open cup reads lower after because: (A) matter was destroyed (B) a gas left the cup (C) the vinegar dried up
3. Does carbon dioxide gas have mass? Use the lab to explain.
Answers
| Question | Answer | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | B | A closed system: the carbon dioxide stays in the bag. |
| 2 | B | The carbon dioxide escaped into the room. Matter is not destroyed. |
| 3 | Yes | When it left the open cup, the scale went down by its mass. A yes with the lab as evidence is a full answer; yes alone is half. |
If your state or umbrella school asks, this lesson covers NGSS MS-PS1-5, NGSS MS-PS1-2.